The Pentagon, September 26, 2003. File photograph by Tech. Sgt. Andy Dunaway, U.S. Department of Defense.
The Pentagon’s $48.3 billion Iran war estimate leaves out damage to U.S. bases
Senators had already been briefed privately on base damage. When a Pentagon budget official gave the public a new war estimate on November 19, the repair bill was still missing.
Arthur Miller put the war’s cost through November 13 at $48.3 billion. Operations and replacement equipment were counted. Repairs to damaged U.S. installations were outside that estimate.
The Pentagon could tell senators what the Iran war had cost through November 13 to the nearest hundred million dollars: an estimated $48.3 billion. It could not tell the public, at the same hearing, what it would cost to repair the American bases Iran had hit. Five senators had already asked for that accounting in writing. Their requested deadline passed more than two weeks before the hearing.
Arthur Miller, a Pentagon budget official nominated to oversee Navy finances, explained the boundary on November 19. His estimate covered military operations, munitions and replacement equipment. When Connecticut Democrat Richard Blumenthal asked about damage to U.S. installations, Miller said he did not have that figure. Mississippi Republican Roger Wicker, who chairs the Senate Armed Services Committee, told him to get the committee an answer as soon as he could.
Blumenthal had signed the October 18 letter to Admiral Brad Cooper, head of U.S. Central Command. The senators said Cooper had already given the committee a damage estimate in a classified briefing. They asked for answers by November 2. Miller’s inability to produce a number at his hearing leaves two different questions on the record: what estimate the military had shared privately, and how much it would actually spend on repairs.
Those numbers can diverge. A damaged installation might be rebuilt, replaced elsewhere or left closed. The senators asked what repair contracts had been awarded and what it had cost to shift operations, including delays to supply runs. They cited the relocation of a Navy logistics hub after damage in Bahrain. Even if the Navy never rebuilds a particular facility, moving the work can still cost money.
Adding a reported reconstruction estimate to $48.3 billion would produce a bigger headline and an unreliable total. A repair contract creates an obligation. An assessment of what it might cost to replace a building does not. The useful answer to Wicker’s request would put three figures side by side: the damage estimate Cooper shared with senators, the repair costs the Pentagon has committed to and the relocation expenses already counted in operations. Taxpayers could then see both what the war has cost and which bills are still ahead.
Summary
Senators had already been briefed privately on base damage. When a Pentagon budget official gave the public a new war estimate on November 19, the repair bill was still missing.
Key facts
Arthur Miller put the cost of the Iran war through November 13 at about $48.3 billion, excluding repairs to U.S. installations.
Five senators wrote to U.S. Central Command on October 18 asking for a public accounting after a classified damage briefing.
At the November 19 hearing, Senate Armed Services Chair Roger Wicker asked Miller to provide the missing figure as soon as he could.
Follow the public record
Source Trail
Primary records and direct statements
Independent reporting and analysis
Get the next investigation in your inbox
One email a week. Receipts only. Free.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.