The Newsmax complaint describes two contractual alternatives. One allocates ad spots and the other splits revenue. Gen Us graphic based on the November 18 filing.
Fox promised to keep Roku open. Newsmax wants to know who gets the ad money.
The Justice Department cited promises about carriage and search. A rival’s lawsuit points to a different kind of leverage in the contract it already has with Roku.
A channel can stay on Roku and still lose control over what it earns there. Newsmax’s challenge to Fox’s purchase turns on the difference between access to viewers and the price of reaching them.
A promise to keep a television channel on the screen leaves open a question worth money every commercial break. Who gets to sell the ads? In a federal complaint filed November 18, Newsmax describes two arrangements available to Roku under its contract. Roku can take 30% of the channel’s ad inventory and keep what it earns selling those spots. Or it can sell the whole inventory under a separate program and pay Newsmax 55% of the revenue.
Those percentages measure different things. The first divides the spots themselves. The second divides the proceeds after a sale. Newsmax also says it must ask Roku to reclaim inventory under the first arrangement. These are powers the rival broadcaster says Roku already had. What changed on November 6 was who owns the company on the other side of the contract.
Fox completed the purchase that day. Its newly formed digital division includes both Roku and Tubi, Fox’s own streaming service. Fox chief Lachlan Murdoch said the combined business would protect the choice and openness that drew viewers and partners to Roku. Asked about the lawsuit, Fox told the Daily Beast the complaint was without merit and pointed to the regulatory review.
The Justice Department’s account of that review spells out several commitments. Fox agreed to keep carrying non-Fox content for at least three years on terms consistent with Roku’s historical practice, to avoid discrimination in search results and to let people rearrange the apps on their home screen. The department also cited commitments on access to data products and safeguards for partners’ commercially sensitive data. Investigators found that viewers could switch platforms and that using Roku to hurt competing channels would cost the combined company money and damage its reputation. It left open the possibility of acting if circumstances change.
Newsmax is asking a court to intervene. Its complaint is one competitor’s account of the risks, and the contract provisions it cites do not establish that Fox has used them against it. They do identify what to watch. A viewer can check whether a channel is missing. A viewer who finds it exactly where it was yesterday has no way to tell from the screen how much of the next ad sale the channel gets to keep.
Summary
The Justice Department cited promises about carriage and search. A rival’s lawsuit points to a different kind of leverage in the contract it already has with Roku.
Key facts
Fox closed its Roku purchase on November 6. Its digital division now includes Roku and Tubi.
The Justice Department cited Fox’s commitment to keep carrying non-Fox content for at least three years consistent with Roku’s historical practice.
Newsmax says Roku can take 30% of its channel’s ad inventory under one arrangement or pay Newsmax 55% of revenue under another.
Follow the public record
Source Trail
Primary records and direct statements
Independent reporting and analysis
Get the next investigation in your inbox
One email a week. Receipts only. Free.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.