///GEN_US

Myanmar submitted thirteen reports. The ICJ voted eleven to four that it breached its evidence-preservation obligation. Gen Us graphic based on the judgment.

WorldOriginal reportingBy Gen Us Investigations

Myanmar filed all 13 reports the World Court ordered. It still lost the evidence on the ground.

The World Court found that remains of at least five Rohingya villages burned after it ordered Myanmar to preserve evidence. Judges split 11 to 4 on that finding.

/// Gen Us Original
The argument

Myanmar’s ministry pointed to its court filings as evidence of good faith. The judges credited every filing, then traced what happened at village sites after the order took effect.

2
Minute read
2
Receipts

Myanmar’s foreign ministry could point to thirteen reports it had filed with the International Court of Justice. Every one was accounted for. So were the remains of at least five Rohingya villages burned in May 2020, four months after the judges ordered the state to preserve evidence. In its November 19 judgment, the court recorded both facts in consecutive paragraphs.

The Gambia, which brought the case, conceded a limit on what it could prove with photographs of ruined villages. Most burning and destruction dated to 2017 and 2018, before the January 2020 order existed. To establish a breach of that order, it mattered what happened afterward.

Myanmar cited a presidential directive barring officials from destroying property that could serve as evidence. It also produced a 2022 township order against occupation of property left by displaced residents. The judges examined what happened at the sites themselves. They found convincing evidence that the remains of at least five villages in Buthidaung Township burned in May 2020 and that the state completed a government base in 2021 on former Rohingya village land in Maungdaw Township. The court described witness accounts checked against satellite imagery and government reports.

In its November 20 response, the foreign ministry invoked the thirteen filings as evidence of good faith. It disputed the court’s treatment of evidence and pointed to six dissenters on the central finding that Myanmar committed genocide. That finding split the court 9 to 6. The evidence-preservation question drew a different majority, 11 to 4.

More judges still, thirteen of the fifteen, ordered Myanmar to investigate people reasonably suspected of prohibited acts in the 2017 operations and to prosecute where warranted. For those investigations, a report filed on schedule cannot give a witness back the place where something happened. The court credited Myanmar for every report it owed. It also established which pieces of the physical record were gone by the time the reports were finished.

Summary

The World Court found that remains of at least five Rohingya villages burned after it ordered Myanmar to preserve evidence. Judges split 11 to 4 on that finding.

Key facts

Get the next investigation in your inbox

One email a week. Receipts only. Free.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.

Read Next

Share this story